By Rush PT
A smart scale can measure your body weight, but the “muscle mass” number on its app is an estimate. A small rise after a few weeks of lifting could reflect several things. That reading alone can’t tell you whether you’ve gained muscle or how much. The decimal point is doing a fair bit of work there.
If you’re deciding whether your training is working, start with the change you care about. Lifting the same weight for more controlled reps tells you something about that lift. Getting the shopping up the stairs with fewer stops tells you something about that trip. A scale reading answers a different question.
What the scale measures and what it estimates
The scale measures weight. The metal pads on many smart scales also send a small electrical current through part of your body and measure how much the body opposes it. This is called bioelectrical impedance analysis, or BIA. The device uses that reading and information such as your height, age and weight in a formula that estimates body composition.
Water helps conduct the current, so the reading can change with how much water is in your body and where it’s distributed. The result also depends on the device and its formula. The pads aren’t scanning or weighing your muscles separately.
It helps to read the label carefully. Fat-free mass includes everything other than fat, including water and bone. Lean soft tissue, a term you’ll see in reports from DXA scans, excludes bone mineral but still includes water and tissues other than skeletal muscle. These measures overlap, but a change in one can’t be converted straight into kilos of muscle gained or lost.
What the comparison studies found
In a 2021 hospital study of three smart scales, the devices generally measured body weight close to the DXA reference values. Their fat mass estimates were further off, with median differences of a few kilograms. About 50 adults were assessed per model, and each person used just one of the three. It was a snapshot of particular devices in patients referred for scans, so it doesn’t tell us how well any of those scales tracks an individual’s muscle gain over time.
A study by Siedler and colleagues did look at change over time. It compared 15 impedance devices with a laboratory model in 73 healthy adults aged 19 to 50. Thirty-seven returned 12 to 16 weeks later. The devices could give very similar readings on repeat tests, yet their agreement with the laboratory model on changes varied. Some performed better than others. The outcome was body fat percentage, so the results don’t validate an app’s muscle gain figure.
Even a scan can be influenced by the conditions on the day. In a 2025 experiment with 16 active adults, whole-body lean tissue on DXA averaged about 0.8 kg higher in the condition where participants drank water before testing. The researchers didn’t detect a significant change in the size of the thigh muscle they imaged by ultrasound. That result illustrates why a lean tissue reading can move over a short period. It doesn’t give you a correction factor for a bathroom scale.
Make the reading earn its place in your training log
If you like having the number, use the same device and compare readings taken at a similar time and under similar conditions. A check after your usual morning routine is easier to compare with another ordinary morning than with a reading after a hot outdoor session. Keep your usual fluid habits. One jump in the app doesn’t need a change to your training.
For a strength goal, pick one exercise you already do comfortably and record the version, load, reps and how hard the set felt. Compare a few similar sessions. For example, going from eight to ten controlled reps with the same dumbbell and a similar effort is a useful change if the movement and setup stayed comparable. A different machine, a shorter movement or a longer rest can change the result too.
The 2026 ACSM position stand on resistance training treats strength, muscle size and physical function as separate outcomes. Its review found that resistance training can improve all three in healthy adults. Your log can show you’re doing an exercise or an everyday task better even when it can’t tell you whether the muscle itself grew.
If your aim is to get stronger, let those repeatable training results guide your next conversation with your coach. Our guide to tracking fitness progress has a simple way to start. If you’d like help choosing a measure that fits your goal, ask Rush PT about personal training in Sydney’s Eastern Suburbs or online coaching.